Orthodox Outlet for Dogmatic Enquiries Church Fathers

Incurable and long-term illnesses

 


Bible reading for Sunday of the Paralytic man - John 5:1-15
Homily delivered at the Sacred Monastery of Komnenion of Larisa on the 1-5-1988

Transcript of the homily of the reposed Elder Athanasios Mitilineos

 ]



"....My beloved, the story about the healing of the paralytic man at the Pool of Bethesda is well known. There was this huge cistern of water, around which there was always a swarm of ailing people waiting patiently, given that God's love provided healing (albeit limited) to those who could immerse themselves whenever the pool’s waters were swirled violently by the presence of an angel of God.  We can clearly identify from this Gospel narration that their healing was not a natural one, that is, it wasn’t the result of a thermal spring, but a direct, supernatural energy by God.

Alongside that cistern - the 'Pool', as mentioned by the Evangelist John – was also a paralyzed man for a very long time; he had been waiting there for 38 whole years, hoping to enter the water in time, while it was being swirled by the angel, so that he would be healed.

The Evangelist John notes: “And there was some person there, having thirty-eight years with his illness.”  We become dizzy, my beloved, when we hear that an illness lasted 38 whole years! And what kind of illness was it? Paralysis... Can a person really endure such a long-term illness, mainly psychologically? Thus, we are looking at the phenomenon of incurable and long-term illness. It is a phenomenon that is unfortunately not at all rare in our day and age. And there are indeed cases of people who are incurably ill and have been suffering for a very long time - either from birth, or from an accident that happened to them, or from an illness that had appeared at some point in their lives; and when all of them do remain disabled thereafter, for life, they are unable to live as all people normally live and move. And this, my beloved, can happen to all of us; to others and to us. To all of us.

But we might ask, if that happens to others, that is, to someone who might be a relative, or a familiar person, or our neighbor, or a friend, then how should we present ourselves in the presence of such a person, who is incurably ill? The first thing we have to do is to maintain a tireless friendly companionship with them; with a conversation that we will have with them when we are together – one that will not tire them. We should not turn our discussion towards the issue of their illness. If possible, we should take their thoughts away from their situation.

I will give you an example. When we go to express our condolences to a person or a family for their loss, because someone close to them has died, we should not revolve our conversation around the person of the reposed one – of the deceased. Because, do you know what the result will be? When we leave, these people will be even more distressed. They often mention this, by saying “We don't want visitors, because visitors make us more depressed”.  Why? Because the visitors don't know how to act when they go to give their sympathies to the mourners.  And I would like to emphasize this point: that in our discussions with them, we should avoid the topic that is already tormenting the minds of the others.  Likewise with a sick person, we should distance their thoughts from their problem, at least for as long as we stay with them, in order to take the issue of their illness away from their thoughts. We should talk about various other things. That way, we will truly be giving them – even if only for a little while – a restful oasis.

Furthermore, when we go to visit them, we can and should always bring them something - even if it's something small; even if it is not something costly - for example a sweet, a flower, a rose that we cut from our garden. Or if you want, even a useful object, or a book – not necessarily an expensively bound one with gold print; just a small booklet - a cheap book, which, when they read it, will keep them company for when we are away. We can also tackle any external chores of theirs - bureaucratic affairs - certificates, or a certain specific need. We can go to the market and shop for them, etc. We can even pray with them. But we must always tell them that we too pray for them. Can you see how much we can offer to a person who is bedridden, or in a chair or in an armchair and unable to get up?

However, it is very important for us to try to ensure that their soul is not overwhelmed by despair; we must in every way stimulate their hope. Because... who can say that one day a medicine won’t be discovered and they will be cured? Or, that even a miracle of God may intervene? Don’t miracles always take place? Undoubtedly, yes. I could in fact tell you, that if the paralytic man in today's Gospel passage had become disillusioned and hadn’t gone to the Pool of Bethesda, the Lord would undoubtedly not have approached him. But He did see him, because the paralytic always had hope that something would be done for him there, at the Pool - even though that hope had extended for 38 whole years.

But if God's love and God's discipline permit this incurable and long-term disease - it could easily be a long-term but not incurable one, but it can also naturally be long-term when incurable - so I will take them both into account. Anyway, if it can happen to us, how should we handle it? I would like to tell you how we should handle it, with a true story that is close to us.

A few - very few - years ago, a man had died in the “Asylum for the Incurable” in Athens. I will even tell you his name. His name was Panayiotis Stylianopoulos. You may have even heard mention of his name. He In fact, on the 7th of December in 1958, had received a special diploma from the Athens Academy, awarding him for his beneficial social activity. How did this happen? Listen up and learn. At the age of 19 he became paralyzed. And then he was admitted to the “Asylum for the Incurable”. I don't know if it's still called “Asylum for the Incurable”, but still, that’s a terrible title. So, when this 19-year-old youth entered and had seen the sign “Asylum for the Incurable” outside, he was overcome by despair: “Does that imply I will never leave here? Will I only get out of here when I’m dead?' he asked... So, you can understand how despair came and literally crushed his soul.

God's Grace, however, illuminated him. So he began to study the Bible. Then hope entered him and he began to feel consoled. And so, it occurred to him that there are others who are surely worse off than him – for example, the blind, which he had quite rightly acknowledged. So this paralyzed man began to think about what he could do to help the blind. He began to imagine making a machine that would produce books printed in the Braille system for the blind - which the blind could read by touch. I don't know if you've seen any books that are written for the blind. This machine of his achieved it. In fact, this invention was considered unique in the whole world. It was adjusted to his bed (by others of course), and so, he would sit on the bed - because he was paralyzed from the waist down, but his hands were not paralyzed - and thus began, my beloved, to type books for the blind, from the book with the Alphabet for young blind children, to university books, religious books, the Holy Bible... everything... he had supplied 10,000 blind people in Greece with books.

I remember once, a few years ago, I was visited by a girl who had finished - yes, she had truly finished - high school, and I think perhaps also University, later on. When she was about 5-6 years old, while playing with her sister with a hand grenade they had found outdoors (this incident had taken place here, in Larissa), she was left blind when the grenade exploded. So I asked her: “How do you manage, my child, and are able to study and read?” (She was the student who was the top of her class at the time, in high school – in the last grade)... 

She explained: “Thanks to Mr. Stylianopoulos”.

What is he?” - I asked – “a Doctor?”

Don't you know”, she says to me, “Mr. Stylianopoulos?”

He was the same Stylianopoulos whose story I just described to you...

So, my beloved, that is why this man was so great and beneficial. The Athens Academy - as I told you – came along to award him for his contribution to society... to award the one who had offered his services so beneficially to the incurably blind. I forgot to tell you that he also gave a tutorial to those people who had become blind – old people, or those blinded after an accident or any other cause - who of course were educated, but now were no longer able to read. So he tutored them himself, helping them to learn to read. Who helped them? That incurably paralyzed man...

This story is, I think, a very eloquent answer. What did we say he did first?  He received hope from God. A huge asset. He received hope from God, then he considered how there were others in a worse condition than his.

By the way... there’s a colloquial (Greek) expression that we use frequently, but haven’t wondered what it implies: “Not worse!”'  What does it imply? It is used when we warn someone seriously, saying “What on earth are you doing – or what were you thinking? Not worse!” That is, we are wishing them 'May it not get worse!'. That is what the expression ‘Not worse! implies.

So, what did he do then? He put his strengths to work - the strengths that he had;  he surpassed himself, and also ignored his disability. That's a huge thing. He didn’t grumble. He studied the Bible and came to be a spiritual man. He didn’t grumble. He didn’t feel resentful towards God. He had a lot of patience. With such an attitude, we can clearly see how he helped himself by surpassing himself, because he had something to keep him preoccupied, without focusing on his own problem. He had something to tackle. And he eventually overcame the darkness of his despair.

But, dear ones, as you can see, in a long-term or incurable illness, there is always a theological depth. A very important theological depth. If we ask what illness is, we see that the key to the answer is given to us in the same Gospel passage, and it is given by the Lord. When the Lord healed this man and then met him in the temple after a few days, the Lord said to him: “Behold, you have become healthy; Sin no longer, lest something worse befalls you.”' Ahhh... so that means there is a connection between sickness and sin; that is why the Wisdom of Sirah notes: “Stay away from transgression (=Do not commit, stay away from sins) “and keep your hands accountable, and cleanse your heart from all sin.”  Take note: “stay away from sin” – why? Because in Wisdom of Sirah in chapter 38 verse 15, “the sinner – by acting against the One who created him -  will fall into the hands of a physician, In other words, 'he who sins will himself fall into the hands of a doctor'. There ought to be signs, I think... I don't know... inside hospitals - with this inscription. “He who sins against the One who created him (=his Creator) falls into the hands of a doctor”....

So: you don’t fast according to God? Some day you will be fasting according to a doctor’s instructions, and so on....

Consequently, we can see that illness constitutes a means of punishment – a pedagogical punishment- for rectification. But, the interpreter Theophylactos asks: “But do all sicknesses come from sin?” (are all diseases, sicknesses on account of our sins?). “Not all of them, but most of themhe says; “for some of them are for sins, as in the case of this paralytic” (in today's Gospel reading on the paralytic), “and the other ones are for  prospering and restoration, as in the case of Job, so that his virtue would be shown.” (i.e., there are also sicknesses that are not on account of sins). “And an example of this” - says Theophylactus – “is Job, who had no sins”... But of course no-one is entirely sinless, but Job had no sins that would justify his sufferings to be incurable - he had no grave sins...  It was for that very reason, my beloved, that God gave them to Job... He had given permission to the devil, so that Job’s virtue would eventually prosper even more.

Then, let’s recall the very words of the Lord, when that blind man whom the Lord had healed (it is in the forthcoming Gospel reading) where the disciples asked Him: “Lord, who had sinned? (he was born blind) His parents or him?' Then one might wonder: When did he manage to sin, if he was born blind?  But that’s another story. Come here next Sunday to hear it – I will tell it to you. Anyway, the Lord replied to that question: “Neither he nor his parents.” His blindness had been allowed, so that God would be glorified (when Jesus Himself would be miraculously restoring his vision.)

So, we see there are also instances that are not because of sins! Dear friends, if we know a disabled or seriously ailing person who has indeed committed sins, let us never say: 'Look, God has punished him for his sins'. Let us not say it, lest sickness leaves him and comes to us. Let's not say it, but instead let us say: “May God show mercy; may God educate through sickness; the ‘why’ and the ‘how’ and God's plans cannot be deciphered by us - they are inaccessible to our knowledge.”

For this reason, since the purpose is pedagogical, we should learn this pedagogy of God when an illness comes to us, trace God’s plans as much as we can, and end up giving praise to God. In other words, we should not complain like “oh, look what happened to me... what has befallen me...” but we should say: 'Glory to God!'

If you see someone who is bedridden and they are suffering from one thing or another and they have no prospect of getting up, yet you hear them say: 'Glory to God', that person has matured, they have progressed spiritually - and that is very important.

It is also characteristic that the paralytic was a “someone”. Speaking of which... what was his name? Well, It is not of importance that his name wasn’t written in the Gospel text... He was “some person”.  

This is how the Evangelist John puts it:  And there was a certain person....” (some person)... What does that signify? It means that every person, anyone, who is anonymous to us, is nevertheless eponymous to God. God knows each one of us. If I may use the expression, Christ went ‘expressly’ to him. Why? Because Christ knew him.  You may ask “how come He knew the man?” Well, wasn't Christ God? That’s how He knew the man.  So, one must NEVER say: “God doesn’t know me”... or, “He has forgotten me”.

A little further down, we will see this: “And (Jesus), knowing that the (paralytic) man was already thus for a long time...”, what did He do?  He went to that man!  And how did Christ know about him?  Well, that’s what I want to tell you, my beloved: that God is neither unaware, nor does He forget. So, don’t ever say “God has forgotten me”. Or that blasphemous phrase: “There is no God. Because if there was, why has he left me (beware! A second blasphemy!)... to be tortured?'  Is it God who torments man? What is He? A torturer?!

Jesus - on seeing him lying on the ground (per the pursuant verse) and knowing that he (the paralytic) was already thus for a long time, says to him: do you want to become healthy?”

Jesus saw the paralytic man “lying on the ground”. What does “lying on the ground” imply? It is suggesting that the man’s body was stretched out on the ground in a horizontal position.  It certainly wasn’t the positon we take when we want to sleep; it was an unnatural positon – a different kind – because that person was unable to take a different position in order to get up... It was as though the Lord was saying to him - when he saw him lying on the ground: “I, your Creator, had fashoned you to be upright.  So how come you are now lying down on the ground, horizontally? Who threw you down? I had fashioned you as upright.”

You do realize, my beloved, that this incident was symbolic of the fallen image of God’s creation (Adam)of the fallen man, of fallen humankind? Because that is what drew the Son of God to the paralytic: fallen humankind. It drew the Son of God to come in our midst in order to raise us up again.

“And knowing that he (the paralytic) was already thus for a long time...”  How ‘long’ was that time? Of course He knew that, because (His) divine nature informs (His) human nature. Christ knew it, supernaturally.... Well, it was the time of pre-Christ humankind. It was the ‘long time’ that mankind has remained fallen.. the time before Christ, for all of mankind... It was the time that had led humanity into paralysis. A little longer - as a wise man had said - and humanity would have become a corpse. It would have died. So, the Son of God had chosen the most suitable time to become incarnate. It is what the Apostle Paul wrote to the Colossians: “When the fullness of time came” (the fulfilling, the proper moment, the time had come), “God sent forth His Son, who was born of woman, that we might savour the adoption...” (receive adoption from God).

And when Jesus saw him lying on the ground, what happened? “He says to him....” (Yes, with His incarnation, God opens a dialogue with man, He talks with man); Mount Sinai no longer covers itself with smoke, nor is it set ablaze by the presence of God. People no longer hear God's voice from Mount Sinai and are afraid they will die of fear... God's voice becomes human; it becomes very human. And what does Jesus say now, on commencing a dialogue with the paralytic? “Do you want to become healthy?” God goes as far as asking the man if he wanted to be upright again... healthy... completely healthy...

He also wants in that way to show God’s respect for the freedom He had bestowed on man. Because you may actually not want to become healthy... Because perhaps the question... (but, really, what kind of question is “Do you want to become healthy?”)... Well, there are way too many people who do not want to get well. It’s quite simple: you want to not have cancer, to not get cancer...

At least in one case... in one case; In fact, the first: “Don't smoke!” But you do smoke, therefore you don't want to not get cancer. In which case, the question: 'Do you want to get well?' is not inappropriate. 

I'm sorry I don't have time to show this to you... many people love the situation they are in and don't want to get well! Strange? And yet it's real, it's true. However, this is where we see the freedom that God gives to man, by asking him: “Do you want to get well?” implying “I'm not going to forcefully make you healthy.”

The Lord also wants to show him that, apart from the Pool, it is also Jesus who heals - not the pool alone. Or rather, we should say that Jesus literally is the One who heals and that He alone is the One who heals. And the Pool? It was a “foreshadowing”.

Jesus now comes, preparing a new Pool - the Christian Baptism - which gives us wholeness and also grants us the Adoption.

Dear friends, everything that today’s Gospel reading narrates, and whichever other passages mention miracles of Christ in the Gospels, the Apostle Peter has described in a very concise phrase how the Lord spent His earthly life. How did he spend it? It is in the book of Acts 10:38: “...who went through life doing good and healing those who were oppressed by the devil.”

But Christ wants a basic prerequisite. Humanity, from the moment it came to know Christ, must no longer sin. The peoples - unfortunately the Christian peoples - should not sin. Because they came to know Christ.

That is why apostasy - our distancing from Christ - is a grave sin. And that which Christ had said: “lest something worse befalls you”: what else do you think the “something worse” is, if not the acknowledgement of the Antichrist? Is there anything worse than that? When you abandon Christ and admit the Antichrist?

This also applies, my beloved, to each person personally. Each of us may have been, in the short or long term, a paralytic of sin; one who was paralyzed by sin. Now that he has become healthy and now knows Christ, let him be careful, because then - as the Lord Himself says in the Gospel of Matthew 12:45 – “that man’s final state will be worse than his previous state”'.

My beloved, whoever is truly intelligent according to Christ (as we all want to be intelligent – a truly intelligent person), will fill his soul with the fear of God - a fear that if he loses Christ, he will lose himself...."

***********

FOR THE GLORY OF THE HOLY TRIUNE GOD - and with immeasurable gratitude to our spiritual guide, the reposed Elder Athanasios Mitilineos,

Digital processing and editing of the transcript of the homily: Eleni Linardaki, philologist

 

SOURCES:

Greek article:  https://www.impantokratoros.gr/C1FCB0EB.el.aspx

•Transcript of a speech by the hand of the honorable Mr. Athanasios K.

https://www.arnion.gr/

 

Translation: A.N.

 

 

 

Article created:  23-5-2025.

Updated on:  23-5-2025.